Skip to main content

SUSTAINOW

Why assessing the cumulative effects of offshore wind is still a challenge

As offshore wind farms multiply across Europe’s seas, their combined effects on marine life and coastal communities increasingly matter but remain difficult to assess. The SUSTAINOW report “Enduring sectoral challenges” finds that assessments rely largely on expert judgement, that methods, boundaries and timeframes vary widely between countries, and that shared data systems and thresholds for acceptable change are still missing.

What are cumulative effects, and how are they assessed?

Cumulative effects are the combined consequences of multiple plans, projects and activities acting on the same environment or community over time and space. A single wind farm may have a limited impact, but several in the same sea basin, alongside shipping, fishing, cables and climate change, multiply the potential impact. These effects can be additive (the total equals the sum of the parts), synergistic (the total is greater than the sum), or antagonistic (one effect partly offsets against another).

Cumulative Effects Assessment (CEA) is the process used to evaluate these combined effects. EU law requires it in the environmental assessment of plans (SEA) and projects (EIA), as well as under rules protecting nature and the marine environment. In practice, however, it has long been difficult to apply. In the sample of assessment reports reviewed for the SUSTAINOW study, around one in ten did not address cumulative effects. Guidance is also scarce: among the countries studied, only the UK has dedicated CEA guidance, and only one existing guide targets offshore wind.

Where does cumulative effects assessment need to improve?

The report, Enduring Sectoral Challenges, draws on a review of scientific literature, a review of SEA and EIA reports from seven countries (Denmark, Estonia, Germany, Ireland, Portugal, Spain and the United Kingdom), and interviews with 20 experts from authorities, consultancies, research and industry.

Research has produced more advanced CEA methods and tools, but they are rarely used in practice. Most of the challenges the report identifies concern how assessments are carried out, and many experts point to the lack of dedicated guidance:

  • Assessments are mostly qualitative: They rely heavily on expert judgement, which can introduce bias. Figures are only produced at project level, for a few issues such as porpoise disturbance from pile-driving noise or bird collisions with turbines.
  • Methods vary widely between plans and projects, and between countries, which makes results hard to compare. Of the 20 experts interviewed, 11 said they do not follow a systematic method.
  • Spatial boundaries are inconsistent, ranging from a few hundred metres around a site to an entire Exclusive Economic Zone.
  • Timeframes are often too short: The surveys used to describe the starting situation often last only one or two years, but some effects only become visible after a decade or more of operation. Also, each assessment starts from today’s baseline, missing past effects, climate change, and recovery times.

Assessing cumulative effects is also technically difficult. There is no agreed way to combine multiple indicators into a single cumulative effect index, and predictive models are rarely checked against what actually happens after construction. Assessments of similar projects can therefore reach very different conclusions. On top of this, there is still no central, shared system for socio-environmental data.

Which environmental and social risks should be prioritised?

Environmental risks vary across a wind farm’s life cycle:

  • Construction: underwater noise, especially from pile driving, is the main risk. It disturbs and displaces marine mammals, fish, birds and bats, and can damage the hearing of species such as the harbour porpoise.
  • Operation and maintenance: turbines bring collision and displacement risks for birds, changes to currents and seabed habitats, and non-native species. On the other hand, foundations create a “reef effect”, and where fishing is excluded, wind farms can act as de facto marine protected areas.
  • Decommissioning: the effects remain largely unknown, as few wind farms have been decommissioned. Removal could destroy the reef habitats formed on foundations.

Social risks have received less attention, but they are often the most debated. Most tensions arise between fishing, the protection of marine nature, and offshore wind. Wind farms can push fishers into less favourable grounds. Visual changes to the seascape can also affect tourism and coastal wellbeing, while excluding local communities from planning increases the risk of opposition.

Why does SUSTAINOW's work matter in this context?

Offshore wind farms are scaling up quickly across Europe, driven by the European Green Deal. As more projects are planned in the same sea basins and across national borders, assessing each wind farm in isolation is no longer enough. Without shared methods, comparable data and clear thresholds for acceptable change, small effects can accumulate unnoticed until they become severe or irreversible.

For SUSTAINOW, this report is the starting point for the next stages:

  • The identified challenges will inform a new framework for assessing cumulative effects, which aims to tackle as many of them as practically possible.
  • This framework will then feed into a tool supporting informed and sustainable decisions on where to site offshore wind farms.
  • The identified risks will be considered in data collection and in the development of SUSTAINOW’s shared data space.

 

Explore the report here:

Enduring sectoral challenges

Ainhoa González and Fatemeh Rezaei
We're just getting started

Catch wind of our progress